Tag: Buoyancy

  • Why Sidemount Appeals to Me More Than Twinset

    Why Sidemount Appeals to Me More Than Twinset

    Technical Diving • Sidemount • Diver Development

    Why Sidemount Appeals to Me More Than Twinset

    I already own twin 12s. The problem is that somebody eventually has to pick the bloody things up.

    I already have a twinset.

    So my interest in sidemount is not based on never having considered the obvious alternative.

    Manifolded twins make complete sense for a lot of diving, and plenty of very good technical divers use them.

    But the more I think about the diving I actually want to do, the more sidemount seems to fit me better.

    Not because it is newer.

    Not because it looks more technical.

    And definitely not because I think it will magically make me a better diver.

    It simply seems to solve more of the problems that matter to me.

    The right configuration is not the most impressive one. It is the one that makes sense for the dive and the diver.

    The twinset problem starts on land

    My biggest issue with twinset is not what happens underwater.

    It is everything required to get the thing there.

    Have you ever picked up twin 12s?

    Now add your backplate, wing, regulators and whatever ballast your exposure protection requires.

    That is a substantial lump of equipment sitting on your back before the dive has even started.

    For UK diving, that matters.

    We have already established that some of our dive sites have an unhealthy relationship with car parks, rocks, long walks and inconvenient exits.

    I do not see much virtue in exhausting myself carrying one enormous rigid package to the water when there may be another way of achieving the same goal.

    Sidemount changes the logistics

    One of the big attractions of sidemount is being able to move the cylinders independently.

    Instead of carrying twin 12s as one giant unit, I can move cylinders separately and clip them on nearer the water where the site allows it.

    That immediately changes the physical cost of the dive day.

    Easier entry.

    Easier exit.

    Less weight sitting on my spine while walking around on land.

    Given how much I already think about conserving energy before a UK dive, that matters enormously to me.

    I want to spend my energy diving, not proving I can carry the dive site on my back.

    Travel makes the difference even bigger

    My diving is not exclusively UK based.

    I travel.

    And airlines tend to become strangely unreasonable when you suggest taking a manifolded set of twin 12-litre steel cylinders as hand luggage.

    Sidemount is much more attractive in that environment.

    I can travel with the harness, wing, regulators and cylinder rigging, then configure suitable hire cylinders at the destination.

    The cylinders do not have to belong to me for the configuration to work.

    Twinset is very different.

    If the destination does not have a correctly configured manifolded twinset available, I cannot simply turn two ordinary hire cylinders into the same setup with a few bits from my luggage.

    For somebody who expects to keep combining UK diving with trips abroad, sidemount feels far more portable.

    My first little taste came from a pony bottle

    Deep Diver was probably where sidemount stopped being an abstract idea for me.

    At 40 metres I was carrying an additional side-slung pony.

    It obviously was not a full sidemount configuration.

    But having a cylinder beside me gave me a small taste of what moving gas off my back could feel like.

    I liked it.

    I liked being aware of the additional gas.

    I liked the planning around it.

    And I liked having the cylinder somewhere I could see and interact with easily.

    That experience was one of the things that pushed me into looking at sidemount much more seriously.

    Independent gas appeals to my brain

    One of the strongest technical attractions for me is having two independent cylinder and regulator systems.

    That changes how I think about redundancy.

    Rather than one manifolded back-gas system, I have gas distributed across independent systems beside me.

    Of course, that also introduces new responsibilities.

    Gas has to be managed properly between cylinders.

    Regulators have to be used deliberately.

    Cylinder pressures have to remain part of the dive plan rather than becoming something I vaguely check whenever I remember.

    Weirdly, that is part of what attracts me.

    I like systems where the “what if?” has an answer before the dive begins.

    Freedom underwater matters too

    Sidemount also looks like it will suit the way I want to move underwater.

    The word I keep coming back to is freedom.

    I do not want to feel locked inside one large rigid package.

    With cylinders beside me, I can interact with them.

    I can reach the valves.

    I can change their position.

    I can trim the cylinders rather than simply accepting wherever a rigid twinset puts the mass.

    That flexibility appeals to me a lot.

    Then there are wrecks

    Wreck diving is one of the big reasons I am interested in technical progression.

    I have already enjoyed being inside wrecks such as the Thistlegorm.

    What interests me is sensible penetration and swim-throughs where there is actually something worth going in to see.

    I am not particularly interested in forcing myself through tiny restrictions purely so I can later tell somebody that I fitted.

    Sidemount gives me more options around wreck structure.

    The cylinders sit alongside me rather than forming one wide rigid block across my back.

    They can also be moved when the environment and training make that appropriate.

    That does not turn every hole in a wreck into an invitation.

    Training, gas, line work, team planning and exit strategy still matter.

    But the configuration gives me options.

    Depth is not really the goal

    This links back to something Deep Diver taught me.

    I am not particularly interested in going deeper simply because I can.

    Forty metres is just forty metres.

    If there is a wreck feature at 38 metres, a swim-through, something unusual to see or a proper training objective, then the depth may be justified.

    If the only objective is touching the number and coming back up, I am not especially interested.

    Technical training appeals to me much more because of what the planning can unlock.

    More options.

    More redundancy.

    Longer planned dives.

    Wreck penetration.

    Structured decompression where appropriate.

    Better answers to failures.

    Technical diving can sound backwards from the outside

    People sometimes hear “technical diving” and immediately translate it to:

    More dangerous diving.

    I understand why.

    The dives can involve greater complexity, different gases, overhead environments or decompression obligations.

    But one thing that appeals to me is how much attention technical training gives to planning failures before they happen.

    What if a regulator fails?

    What if gas disappears?

    What if the planned exit becomes unavailable?

    What gas do I need to solve the problem?

    What is the team doing?

    What is the backup?

    I love that kind of thinking.

    Not because complexity automatically creates safety.

    It does not.

    But deliberate redundancy and planning can create options when something changes.

    I know I am going to get worse before I get better

    I am not expecting to put on a sidemount wing and immediately look like I have been diving the configuration for ten years.

    Quite the opposite.

    I expect a few fairly substantial steps backwards.

    My current trim and buoyancy feel increasingly natural.

    Changing the entire buoyancy and cylinder configuration means learning parts of that again.

    Where does the gas sit?

    Where do the cylinders sit?

    How does the wing behave?

    How does my centre of gravity change?

    How does propulsion feel with cylinders alongside me?

    I know there will be dives where I look significantly less polished than I currently do.

    That is fine.

    I would rather temporarily look like a beginner again than pretend a new configuration requires no relearning.

    Fit the system first

    When I eventually start the sidemount course, the first thing I want is not a long list of impressive drills.

    I want the wing fitted correctly.

    Then I want the cylinders sitting correctly.

    Perfectly horizontal.

    Close to the body.

    Valves where they should be.

    Nothing hanging down like a pair of shopping bags.

    Once the platform is right, then I want to start learning the skills.

    That order matters to me.

    I do not want to spend a course compensating for a badly fitted rig and accidentally turn those compensations into habits.

    The current front runner

    At the moment, the XDEEP STEALTH 2.0 TEC is the system sitting at the top of my list.

    I have also looked at systems from Hollis, Apeks and others.

    The STEALTH keeps pulling me back because it appears to line up with the direction I want my diving to go.

    But this is exactly where I need to follow my own gear rule.

    Test everything and choose what disappears into the background for you.

    I do not want to buy a sidemount system purely because the specification sheet looks good or because I already like another XDEEP product.

    I want experience in the configuration before treating the buying decision as final.

    Sidemount first, then Tec 40?

    I would be happy for my sidemount and Tec 40 progression to overlap.

    But at the moment I am leaning towards doing sidemount first.

    The reason is task loading.

    If I am still consciously thinking about where my cylinders sit, how the wing behaves or how to manage the configuration, that is attention I cannot spend elsewhere.

    Tec 40 will introduce its own procedures and planning.

    I would rather have the basic sidemount platform feeling familiar before I start layering more complexity on top.

    Get the platform boring first. Then add complexity.

    This will not be my “technical-only” setup

    One thing I am already fairly confident about is that I do not see sidemount as something I would save for special technical dives.

    Once I am properly trained and comfortable, I can genuinely see myself using it for around 90% of my diving.

    Recreational dives too.

    If the configuration gives me easier entries, independent gas, clean trim, good travel options and freedom underwater, I do not see why I would leave it at home simply because the planned dive is inside recreational limits.

    The other 10% would probably be the simplest dives where a single cylinder on my XDEEP ZEN is the obvious answer.

    That gives me two configurations rather than forcing one setup onto everything.

    At first, though, I want to use it constantly

    When I first qualify in sidemount, I want to use it whenever reasonably possible.

    Not because I think it is automatically the best setup for every dive.

    Because I need repetition.

    I want gas switching to stop feeling novel.

    I want clipping and unclipping cylinders to stop requiring conscious thought.

    I want the valves to be exactly where my hands expect them.

    I want the trim to become normal.

    I want to stop thinking:

    “I am diving sidemount.”

    And simply think:

    “I am diving.”

    Then it becomes another tool

    Once that confidence exists, my attitude changes.

    Sidemount does not need to win.

    Single-tank backmount does not need to win.

    I just need to choose the tool that makes sense.

    Simple recreational dive where a single cylinder on the ZEN is easiest?

    Use the ZEN.

    Dive where independent cylinders, easier transport, wreck flexibility or technical planning make sidemount the better configuration?

    Use sidemount.

    That is ultimately where I want to end up.

    Final thought

    Sidemount appeals to me more than twinset because it seems to fit both my diving and the way I think.

    It reduces the part I dislike most about twins — carrying an enormous rigid package around on land.

    It works better with the fact that I travel.

    It gives me independent gas systems.

    It gives me more flexibility around wrecks and swim-throughs.

    And it looks like a configuration I could use for far more than technical dives.

    But none of that means I expect it to be easy.

    I fully expect to get worse before I get better.

    I expect to relearn trim.

    Relearn buoyancy.

    Learn new gas habits.

    Learn new equipment habits.

    And spend a lot of time making tiny adjustments until the configuration stops demanding my attention.

    That is the goal.

    Learn it until sidemount stops feeling like sidemount — then choose the right tool for the dive.

  • Task Loading: The Quiet Thing That Can Ruin a Dive

    Task Loading: The Quiet Thing That Can Ruin a Dive

    Human Factors • Task Loading • Dive Safety

    Task Loading: The Quiet Thing That Can Ruin a Dive

    Most dives do not suddenly become complicated. They become complicated one small thing at a time.

    Task loading is one of those diving phrases that sounds more complicated than the idea actually is.

    Put simply, it is what happens when too many things are demanding your attention at the same time.

    The important bit is that none of those things has to be particularly difficult on its own.

    Check gas.

    Watch your buddy.

    Hold depth.

    Navigate.

    Control buoyancy.

    Deal with cold.

    Sort a torch.

    Remember where the exit is.

    Keep an eye on your computer.

    Any one of those is manageable.

    Stack enough of them together and suddenly a diver who was perfectly capable five minutes ago starts making poor decisions.

    Task loading is rarely one big problem. It is lots of small problems all asking for attention at the same time.

    It often starts before the dive

    One thing I have become much more aware of is that task loading does not begin when I descend.

    It can begin hours earlier.

    An early alarm.

    A two-to-two-and-a-half-hour drive.

    Loading cylinders and kit.

    Walking hundreds of metres carrying equipment.

    Getting changed.

    Realising something is in the wrong bag.

    Someone else waiting for you.

    Weather getting worse.

    None of that is underwater yet, but all of it is already using energy and attention.

    That is one reason I bought a gear trolley.

    Carrying a full UK setup for 600 metres before the dive does not make me tougher.

    It just uses energy I would rather have available when I actually need it.

    Equipment can either add load or remove it

    My move to a backplate-and-wing changed how I think about equipment.

    In my earlier setup, if I managed to get horizontal, I could still have a slate, compass, knife, torch, beacon, magnetic clips, several spools, DSMBs and a large console hanging below me.

    Every dangling item was another thing that could move, snag, disappear behind me or need finding.

    I gradually moved towards giving everything a home.

    Routine-use equipment in one pocket.

    Emergency kit in the other.

    Backup torch clipped where I expect it.

    Nothing hanging because I could not decide where else to put it.

    The biggest compliment I can give my XDEEP ZEN is that once I am underwater, I tend to forget it exists.

    Gear that disappears into the background gives your brain somewhere else to spend its attention.

    Overweighting gave me a very literal lesson

    My first open-water drysuit dive gave me one of the clearest examples of task loading I have experienced.

    Including my backplate, I had been given around 19 kg.

    I now know that, depending on the suit, I am generally happier somewhere around 11–14 kg.

    That extra weight did not just mean carrying more lead.

    It meant carrying more gas in the suit to compensate.

    More gas meant a bigger moving bubble.

    A bigger bubble meant more attention needed for trim and buoyancy.

    Holding a two-minute hover at around 11 metres became much harder than it needed to be.

    The lesson was not simply:

    “Too much weight is bad.”

    It was:

    One setup mistake can quietly create several extra jobs for you underwater.

    Then the exit added another layer

    After that dive came the St Abbs exit.

    Rocky shore.

    One-to-two metre swell.

    Heavy steel cylinder.

    Ballast.

    Drysuit.

    Wing.

    Tired legs.

    Someone tried to help and grabbed the corrugated inflator hose on my XDEEP wing.

    The hose came off.

    I went back underwater and surfaced with a wing full of North Sea.

    At that point I was no longer dealing with one problem.

    I was dealing with fatigue, unstable footing, swell, heavy equipment and now a compromised wing.

    That is what stacking looks like.

    It does not require panic.

    It just requires the available mental and physical capacity to keep shrinking.

    Deep diving makes the budget visible

    Deep Diver showed me task loading in a different way.

    At 40 metres, I personally did not notice any obvious narcosis.

    The instructor could not see a difference in my example tasks either.

    But I could absolutely see the gas needle moving.

    I am a greedy breather.

    At that depth, gas use became very visible.

    So I was consciously avoiding wasted movement, checking which gas I was breathing, monitoring depth and watching the NDL disappear surprisingly quickly across repeated deep dives.

    None of those jobs was difficult by itself.

    But they all had to happen.

    That is one reason deeper diving feels different even when you feel calm.

    You have fewer spare resources.

    Forty metres also taught me something slightly embarrassing

    Depth itself can be quite boring.

    I remember hovering calmly, looking up at fish above me, out into the deep blue and down into the nothing as the wall continued beneath us.

    It was beautiful.

    But I also remember thinking:

    Why am I actually down here?

    The dive was costing me more gas, more NDL and more attention purely because of depth.

    That changed how I think about deep diving.

    If depth adds task loading, I want there to be an actual reason for accepting the cost.

    A wreck feature.

    A swim-through.

    Marine life.

    A training objective.

    Something.

    Forty metres simply because the computer says forty is not particularly interesting to me.

    Night diving did the opposite

    This is where task loading gets interesting.

    You would expect night diving to increase it.

    Darkness.

    Lights.

    Different communication.

    Reduced visibility.

    Different navigation cues.

    Yet for me, night diving often feels calmer.

    My world becomes the torch beam, my buddy, my instruments and the next few metres.

    The visual clutter disappears.

    Instead of trying to absorb an entire reef, I am dealing with a smaller bubble of information.

    That suits my brain.

    Night diving did not feel like having less information. It felt like having fewer distractions.

    But only if the kit is right

    Night diving also shows why redundancy has to be thought through beforehand.

    On a night dive, I take a primary light and two strong backups.

    If my primary fails, I do not want the failure itself to create a huge new decision-making problem.

    I know where the backup is.

    I know how to reach it.

    I know I still have another reserve.

    That reduces the mental cost of the failure.

    On a daytime lobster dive, I may only carry one light because losing it does not affect my ability to safely complete the dive.

    Redundancy is not just about carrying more.

    It is about making failures easier to manage.

    A calm buddy reduces load too

    Rescue Diver changed the way I look at other divers.

    I am more willing now to approach somebody who looks uncomfortable and simply ask:

    Hey there, how are you doing?

    I may misread somebody.

    They may be absolutely fine.

    But early communication is cheap.

    Waiting until somebody is visibly overwhelmed is expensive.

    A buddy team should reduce task loading for each other, not add to it.

    That means watching each other, keeping predictable positioning and solving small problems early.

    Team positioning helps

    Gemma and I tend to dive fairly close together.

    One of us leads and the other is slightly offset, around a metre away.

    When Matthew is with us, he takes the opposite side and we form a shallow V.

    It is not some grand tactical formation.

    It is simply easy to understand.

    I know roughly where they should be.

    They know roughly where I should be.

    If somebody is suddenly not there, that change becomes obvious.

    Predictability reduces the amount of active checking needed.

    Good habits should become boring

    I increasingly think one of the goals of training is to make important things boring.

    Checking gas.

    Knowing where the backup torch is.

    Finding the DSMB.

    Reaching the dump valve.

    Looking for your buddy.

    Holding trim.

    These things should not require a committee meeting inside my head.

    The more automatic the basics become, the more spare capacity I have when something genuinely unusual happens.

    That is also why I like practising equipment changes in a pool.

    I would rather discover how something behaves when nothing else matters.

    My warning signs for rising task loading

    I am still learning to recognise this in myself, but there are a few things I pay attention to.

    • I start making larger buoyancy corrections instead of small ones.
    • I stop noticing scenery because I am concentrating on equipment.
    • I repeatedly check the same instrument because I did not properly process the information the first time.
    • I become less aware of where my buddy is.
    • I feel rushed even when nobody is actually rushing me.
    • Simple tasks suddenly feel irritating.
    • I realise I am reacting rather than thinking ahead.

    None of those automatically means the dive must end.

    They mean I should notice what is happening.

    This is where Stop. Think. Assess fits

    Task loading is exactly why I like the Stop. Think. Assess framework.

    When the mental workload starts climbing, the instinct can be to move faster.

    Fix everything.

    Catch up.

    Continue.

    Sometimes the better response is the opposite.

    Stop.

    Stabilise.

    Work out which problem actually matters.

    Deal with that one.

    Pause.

    Reassess.

    When everything feels important, the first job is often deciding what is actually important.

    Final thought

    Task loading is dangerous partly because it does not always feel dramatic.

    You may simply feel busy.

    Slightly rushed.

    Slightly uncomfortable.

    Slightly behind the dive.

    And then another small thing happens.

    The goal for me is not to eliminate task loading.

    Diving will always require us to manage several things at once.

    The goal is to stop wasting capacity on problems I could have removed earlier.

    Better weighting.

    Cleaner equipment.

    Predictable buddy positioning.

    Proper redundancy.

    Enough rest.

    Slower decisions.

    And the willingness to stop when the stack starts getting too high.

    The safest spare capacity is the capacity you never wasted in the first place.

  • Backplate and Wing: Why I Made the Move

    Backplate and Wing: Why I Made the Move

    Gear • Diver Development • Backplate & Wing

    Backplate and Wing: Why I Made the Move

    I thought backplate-and-wing systems were for technical divers. Then Gemma and I tried one — and everything started to feel simpler.

    Like most divers, my first dives were in standard rental jacket-style BCDs.

    That was just what diving looked like to me at the time. You rented the kit, strapped it on, jumped in, and got on with the dive.

    When I later spotted a nearly-new Aqualung Axiom BCD, I snapped it up.

    It was a perfectly good BCD.

    I just never quite felt right in it.

    Gemma was having a similar problem for a different reason. She has a larger chest and found jacket-style BCDs could become sore and uncomfortable after a few dives.

    We had both heard of backplate-and-wing systems, but I originally filed them mentally under:

    Technical diver stuff. Probably not for us.

    That assumption did not survive very long once I started looking into them properly.

    A reef-keeping road trip accidentally became a dive-kit purchase

    Diving was not the only expensive hobby Gemma and I had managed to develop by this point.

    Since starting scuba, we had also become reef keepers.

    So one day we headed towards Manchester and Leeds to look around marine fish shops and, naturally, dive shops.

    One of the places we stopped at was Robin Hood Watersports.

    One thing led to another.

    Then another.

    And somehow both of us ended up ordering XDEEP ZEN backplate-and-wing systems.

    They took roughly six to eight weeks to arrive.

    By then it was early 2025 and far too cold for me to get excited about jumping straight into Ellerton — our local swamp.

    Sorry.

    Lake.

    The boxes finally arrived

    After weeks of waiting, the ZENs finally turned up.

    Unboxing them was probably the first point where the whole BP/W idea stopped being something I had been researching and became an actual piece of dive kit sitting in front of me.

    And the first thing that struck me was how simple it all was.

    XDEEP ZEN backplate and wing still inside its shipping box
    Six to eight weeks of waiting condensed into one cardboard box.
    First look inside the box at the XDEEP ZEN backplate and wing
    First look inside — a lot less bulk than the jacket BCD I was used to.
    Front view of the XDEEP ZEN harness showing shoulder webbing and D-rings
    The harness looks technical at first glance, but it is really just webbing, hardware and a plate adjusted to fit you.
    Side view showing the XDEEP ZEN wing and backplate construction
    Looking at the side construction was when the modular nature of the system really started to make sense.
    Fully assembled XDEEP ZEN backplate and wing ready to be fitted
    The assembled ZEN before its first dive — still looking complicated because it was unfamiliar, not because there was actually much to it.

    That unboxing was also the beginning of me understanding one of the things I now like most about BP/W systems: individual parts actually look like individual parts.

    Wing. Plate. Harness. Hardware.

    Nothing particularly mystical.

    So I hired a five-metre pool

    Rather than wait for open-water weather, I hired the five-metre diving pool at our local swimming pool.

    It cost about £50, with a lifeguard on standby.

    For anyone testing a major new piece of dive equipment, I would genuinely recommend looking into whether you can do something similar locally.

    A controlled pool is a much better place to discover that your harness is wrong, your tank is too high, or something is rubbing than halfway through an open-water dive.

    Gemma and I put the rigs on, walked to the edge, and took a giant stride into the pool.

    Almost immediately, both of us found ourselves naturally settling into horizontal trim.

    We spent roughly an hour at five metres doing nothing particularly glamorous — just practising skills while neutrally buoyant and getting used to the rigs.

    That session told us a lot.

    What surprised me most was how quickly it disappeared

    On land, you absolutely know the ZEN is there.

    Once you add the backplate, cylinder, regulators, ballast and everything else, there is no pretending you are wearing a lightweight fashion accessory.

    But the moment I get into the water and the weight comes off my back, the whole thing seems to disappear.

    That is probably the biggest difference for me compared with a jacket BCD.

    A jacket always felt like something I was wearing.

    The ZEN feels like part of the configuration around me.

    Once I am neutrally buoyant, I barely notice it.

    Anything I no longer have to think about is one less thing competing for attention during the dive.

    Martin wearing his XDEEP ZEN backplate and wing showing how little of the system surrounds his body
    This is what I mean when I say the BP/W disappears into the background. Once it is fitted properly, there is remarkably little around me to notice or fight with.

    From seahorse with a dive shop attached to sleek orca

    Moving to BP/W also changed how I thought about everything else I was carrying.

    In a jacket BCD, even if I managed to get myself horizontal, I could have a slate, compass, knife, small torch, flashing beacon, magnetic hose clips, multiple spools, multiple DSMBs and a huge SPG console all hanging underneath me.

    I was basically a seahorse with a dive shop strapped to him.

    The more I dived the ZEN, the more I started asking a different question:

    What do I actually need for this dive?

    Slowly, the dangling kit disappeared.

    Now, if I need something, it has a proper home.

    The goal is to move through the water more like a sleek orca and less like a mobile clearance aisle.

    My pocket system

    Tech pockets were one of the biggest insights for me because they forced me to think about what I actually expect to use and what is there for emergencies.

    Right pocket — utility and routine-use kit

    • Wetnotes with dive plan or tables
    • Slate when needed
    • Routine DSMB and spool or reel
    • Second backup torch

    My first backup torch is clipped to the right shoulder D-ring and held neatly in place with a ranger band.

    If I am doing something with a lot of note taking — a site survey, PADI AWARE activity or similar — I may use a wrist slate instead.

    Left pocket — safety and emergency kit

    • Spare mask
    • Safety spool
    • Yellow emergency SMB or lift bag where appropriate
    • Spare double-ender
    • CPR mask
    • Shears or other cutting tool
    • Multi-tool where appropriate
    • Waterproof ID card with QR code

    My ID card is there for a reason I hope never matters.

    If I am ever in a situation where I cannot tell somebody who I am, I take some comfort from knowing there is still a route back to my family.

    Redundancy depends on the dive

    I do not believe redundancy means carrying two of absolutely everything.

    It depends on what is required to stay safe and what is actually needed to complete the dive.

    On a night dive, for example, I take a primary light and two strong backups.

    If the primary fails, I can move onto a proper backup and still retain another solid reserve.

    On a daytime lobster dive, I may only take one light because losing that light does not remove my ability to complete the dive safely.

    The important part is not simply carrying the backup.

    I need to know exactly where it is and be able to retrieve it instinctively and safely.

    That includes securing gear inside the pocket. A bolt snap and bit of bungee can stop your shiny new reel from disappearing into the abyss at precisely the moment you need it.

    BP/W helps trim — it does not create skill

    A backplate-and-wing makes it much easier for me to adopt a skydiver-style horizontal position.

    But let us be clear about something.

    You can absolutely wear a BP/W and still seahorse, bicycle-kick and happily work your cylinder down towards 50 bar.

    It is a tool.

    It does not magically give you core strength.

    It certainly does not give you the glutes of a Kardashian.

    Those things take time, practice and — if you are built like me — rather a lot of effort in the gym.

    What the ZEN does for me is make good positioning easier to find and easier to maintain.

    That leaves more attention available for the actual dive.

    Advanced Open Water was when it really clicked

    Our first dives after the pool shakedown were at Ellerton.

    Those dives confirmed that the systems worked.

    But Advanced Open Water was where the benefit really became obvious.

    If I remember correctly, after the Navigation dive both Gemma and I were told that our trim was really good.

    Then we were asked how many years we had been diving.

    When we explained that our Open Water certification had only been the previous May, the reaction was basically disbelief.

    At one point we were even asked if we were secretly PADI test shoppers.

    It was funny, but it also confirmed something useful.

    The BP/W had not magically turned us into good divers.

    It had given us a setup that made good trim easier to maintain, which meant we could concentrate on navigation and the other skills instead of constantly correcting ourselves.

    How we dive as a team

    Gemma and I naturally settle into a fairly tight formation.

    One of us leads and the other sits slightly offset, roughly a metre away and close enough that an arm’s-length movement puts us right alongside one another.

    When Matthew dives with us, he takes the opposite side and we form a shallow V, with the point slightly ahead.

    It keeps everyone visible without feeling crowded.

    The BP/W did not invent that formation, but because Gemma and I are both stable and comfortable in trim, maintaining it feels natural.

    Gemma’s verdict

    Gemma loves her ZEN.

    At this point, I think she would fight me to the death if I suggested we leave it at home and hire a jacket BCD on holiday.

    Either that, or clothes would start disappearing from the suitcase until the BP/W fitted.

    For her, moving away from the jacket also solved the discomfort around her chest that had helped start this whole search in the first place.

    She has little interest in moving into decompression diving.

    That matters because it proves the point: you do not need technical diving to be your destination for BP/W to make sense.

    Jacket BCD vs backplate-and-wing — my experience

    Area Jacket BCD Backplate & Wing My take
    Land comfort Can be very comfortable depending on model Depends heavily on harness choice Close, but BP/W wins for me in hot climates because it is less enclosing
    Travel Usually bulky unless buying a dedicated travel BCD Can be stripped down and packed very small BP/W wins comfortably for me
    Initial setup Put it on and adjust a few straps Needs proper initial fitting Jacket BCD wins at first
    Pockets Often comes with two large built-in pockets Often comes with none BCD wins out of the box — two massive bags of holding
    Weight distribution Usually centred around integrated or belt weight Plate, P-weight, trim pockets and dumpable ballast can all be used BP/W wins by a long way for me
    Trim Absolutely possible with good setup and skill Feels naturally easier for me BP/W wins personally
    Donning and doffing Generally simple and familiar Can take more practice, especially the crotch strap BCD is easier initially
    Repairability Can depend heavily on manufacturer and construction Modular wing, bladder, harness and plate BP/W wins for long-term maintainability
    Customisation Mostly fixed by manufacturer Highly configurable BP/W wins

    Weighting is more interesting than it first appears

    At first glance, you might assume a jacket BCD is automatically lighter.

    Sometimes it is.

    But the more useful question is how you want the total ballast distributed once you are correctly weighted.

    You do not necessarily need 100% of your ballast to be ditchable.

    When properly weighted, removing even a relatively small amount should make you positively buoyant without turning the ascent into a Polaris missile launch.

    A BP/W gives you a lot of freedom in where the weight goes.

    You can choose different backplate materials, add P-weights behind the plate, use trim pockets, integrated dumpable pockets or a traditional weight belt.

    Moving some ballast closer to the centre of the body can also help tune trim.

    I chose aluminium because my diving is roughly a 60/40 split between UK diving and destinations that involve getting on an aircraft.

    Aluminium gives me the structure I want without adding too much luggage penalty.

    If nearly all my diving was cold-water UK diving, I would look much harder at stainless steel because the plate itself could replace some ballast.

    The crotch strap and the hip thrust

    Jacket BCDs are generally easier for people to get in and out of initially.

    With a BP/W, the crotch strap is often the bit that catches people out.

    Once I found the correct hip-thrust motion, however, I discovered I could both make the ladies blush and flick the strap forward far enough to grab it.

    Gemma sometimes gets me to grab hers for her.

    That does highlight a genuine consideration though.

    Somebody with reduced mobility may struggle to retrieve their own strap and may not feel comfortable asking a buddy to do it.

    Harness choice and buddy familiarity matter.

    Myths I tested for myself

    “BP/W is only for technical divers.”

    That was my own assumption before buying one.

    It is simply not how I see it now.

    BP/W can support technical progression, but it works perfectly well for ordinary recreational diving too.

    “It will push you face-down on the surface.”

    I had heard this often enough that Gemma and I deliberately tested it.

    Neither of us has experienced this supposed unavoidable face-plant effect, even when deliberately over-inflating the wing.

    What I have noticed is that I generally sit slightly lower than some divers in jacket BCDs.

    I have seen jacket users sitting with the water below their rib cage. The ZEN normally holds me around mid-chest.

    I am perfectly happy with that.

    Surface swimming on my back is particularly easy.

    You can quite often find me floating face-up before a dive, staring at the sky and generally refusing to be productive.

    “BP/W is too complicated for recreational diving.”

    This is probably the myth that makes the least sense to me now.

    A basic BP/W is extremely simple.

    Plate. Wing. Harness. Cam bands. Cylinder.

    That visual simplicity can make it look more technical, but stripped back is exactly what makes the system simple.

    “They are uncomfortable.”

    That depends on the harness, your body and whether it has actually been fitted correctly.

    There are now recreational harness systems with padding, quick releases and cinching straps if that is what you prefer.

    You do not have to earn some imaginary badge of honour by using a harness you dislike.

    Who should not rush out and buy one?

    I would not automatically make BP/W somebody’s first big equipment purchase.

    You need to know that diving is probably going to become more than the occasional holiday activity.

    If you only do a handful of warm-water dives each year, hiring a good jacket BCD may be the easier and more sensible choice.

    A BP/W starts to make more sense when you know you want to dive regularly, refine your trim, travel with your own configuration, customise your setup, or perhaps move further into advanced or technical diving.

    Buy it because it solves a problem or supports the diver you are becoming.

    Do not buy one because somebody on the internet told you that “proper divers” use them.

    A practical first BP/W setup

    Component Starting point
    Backplate Aluminium for lighter travel-focused use; stainless steel if you want more ballast built into the system
    Wing Donut-style wing sized for the cylinder and exposure protection you actually use
    Harness Either a one-piece Hogarthian harness or a recreational-style harness with quick releases and padding — choose what feels comfortable
    Crotch strap Use one. It keeps the plate stable and stops the system riding up
    Cam bands Two good-quality bands securing the cylinder properly
    Single tank adapter Use one if your chosen plate/wing combination requires it or if it improves cylinder stability

    Basic fit checkpoints

    • Shoulder straps loose enough to slide a fist underneath
    • Shoulder D-rings around collarbone/armpit level
    • Waist buckle slightly right of centre
    • Crotch strap snug rather than restrictive
    • Crotch D-ring roughly a hand-width above the bottom of the plate
    • Top of the plate sitting just below the C7 vertebra at the base of the neck
    • You should be able to reach back and touch the upper plate area with both hands

    Harness choice: use what works for you

    I do not think there is any point telling somebody they must use a one-piece Hogarthian harness if they hate wearing one.

    Recreational harnesses with shoulder padding, quick releases and cinching straps can make the move from a jacket BCD feel much more familiar.

    If you later decide you want to try a continuous one-piece harness, the change does not necessarily cost much.

    The replacement XDEEP webbing I found was around £15.

    So starting with the more familiar harness and experimenting later is perfectly reasonable.

    Fit and comfort matter more than proving you can tolerate a particular harness style.

    Do the first shakedown almost naked

    Not literally.

    Please keep your exposure protection on.

    What I mean is: do not immediately bolt every pocket, torch, reel, camera and accessory you own onto a brand-new BP/W.

    Dive the basic system first.

    If possible, use a pool.

    Leave the pockets and unnecessary extras off and concentrate on fit, trim, tank position and whether anything is restricting movement.

    If you can stick an action camera on the pool wall and record the whole session, even better.

    Watching yourself afterwards can tell you far more about how the configuration is behaving than trying to judge everything purely from how it felt.

    Then make tiny adjustments

    Neither mine nor Gemma’s ZEN was fitted once and then declared finished forever.

    We have both adjusted them a few times.

    The changes are small now.

    Harness length, plate position, how something sits or where a piece of equipment lives.

    The aim is simply to remove more friction.

    Once the big decisions are right, you are sanding off the little annoyances until the system becomes increasingly invisible.

    Does BP/W mean technical diving is next?

    It can be a useful stepping stone.

    For me, the ideas of streamlining, modularity, deliberate equipment placement and trim have fed naturally into my interest in sidemount and technical diving.

    But that does not mean technical diving has to be the destination.

    Gemma is a perfect example.

    She has little or no interest in moving into decompression diving and still absolutely loves her ZEN.

    For her, it is simply the equipment that fits her better and works for the recreational diving she wants to do.

    Equipment should support the diver you are.

    It should not force you towards somebody else’s idea of what your diving should become.

    Final thought

    Some divers will resist anything that feels new in recreational diving.

    I am still not entirely sure where the idea that a backplate-and-wing automatically pushes you face-first into the water came from.

    What mattered to me was testing it.

    Gemma and I got into a controlled pool, used the equipment, practised with it, then took it into open water and kept refining it.

    For us, it worked.

    The more I dive it, the more it disappears into the system.

    The harness fits my body. My equipment has a home. Nothing dangles. Trim takes less thought. The whole configuration creates less friction.

    That is probably the biggest lesson I have taken from moving to BP/W.

    Good dive equipment should not constantly remind you that you are wearing it.

    But I am not going to tell every diver to throw away their jacket BCD.

    For somebody else, that jacket may be the system that fits perfectly and disappears into the background.

    As with all gear: test everything and choose what disappears into the background for you.