One of the biggest things Rescue Diver changed for me was the way I think about action.
Before Rescue, my instinct was often that if I was going to intervene, I needed to know exactly what the correct action was.
Part of that probably comes from the way my brain works. I like systems. I like understanding the problem. I like knowing that the next step is the right step.
The trouble is that real diving does not always give you perfect information.
Sometimes something simply feels different.
A buddy looks less comfortable.
The conditions have changed.
Gas is disappearing faster than expected.
The exit suddenly looks considerably less friendly than it did from the car park.
That is where I have started using a very simple mental framework:
Stop. Think. Assess. Then act.
Why stopping matters
The first step sounds almost embarrassingly simple.
Stop.
But diving has momentum.
We have travelled to the site. We have assembled the equipment. We have paid for the boat. Everyone else is getting ready. The plan says we are going there, doing this, reaching that depth or seeing that wreck.
Once the dive has started, that momentum becomes even stronger.
Swimming becomes continuing.
Descending becomes continuing.
Following the guide becomes continuing.
Sometimes the most useful thing you can do is interrupt that momentum for a few seconds.
Not panic.
Not immediately abort everything.
Just stop long enough to notice what has changed.
Think: what do I actually know?
Once I stop, the next question is:
What do I actually know — and what am I assuming?
That distinction matters.
A buddy swimming differently does not automatically mean they are in trouble.
Someone breathing heavily does not automatically mean panic.
A computer behaving differently from what you expected does not necessarily mean the computer is wrong.
Human beings are very good at filling gaps in information with assumptions.
Underwater, those assumptions can become decisions remarkably quickly.
So I am trying to make myself separate observation from interpretation.
What changed?
What can I see?
What does my computer actually say?
What does my SPG actually say?
What is my buddy actually communicating?
Then I can start thinking about what it means.
Assess: what are my options?
Assessing does not mean performing a fifteen-minute risk assessment while hovering over a wreck.
It means recognising that there is usually more than one response available.
Continue.
Slow down.
Change depth.
Change the route.
Regroup.
Switch equipment.
Surface.
Call the dive.
The earlier you notice something changing, the more options you usually still have.
That is an idea I keep coming back to.
The earlier you pause, the more options you usually have.
Then act
Eventually, thinking has to become action.
Rescue training helped me enormously with this.
Before Rescue, I worried about doing the wrong thing and potentially making a situation worse.
The course helped me understand that useful assistance does not need to be perfect assistance.
If somebody genuinely needs help, doing something useful is normally better than standing nearby waiting until I have designed the theoretically perfect response.
That does not mean acting recklessly.
It means assessing what I can safely do and doing it.
Then reassessing.
Pause and repeat
I have gradually started adding another step to the framework.
Pause.
Because acting changes the situation.
Add gas to a drysuit and buoyancy changes.
Move a stressed diver and their behaviour may change.
Change depth and gas consumption, NDL or decompression obligation changes.
Alter the route and the exit plan may change.
So the process becomes:
Stop. Think. Assess. Act. Pause. Repeat.
That is particularly useful with buoyancy.
One lesson drysuit diving reinforced for me is that pressing an inflator does not instantly produce the result you want.
Make the input.
Give the system time to respond.
Then decide whether another input is actually necessary.
Small problems love company
Serious incidents often look very different when you work backwards through them.
What eventually became a big problem may have started with several very ordinary ones.
Poor sleep.
A rushed morning.
Equipment that was not quite right.
Slightly too much weight.
Colder water than expected.
Worse visibility.
A difficult entry.
A buddy who seems distracted.
None of those things independently has to end the dive.
The danger is when they start stacking.
That is one reason I am increasingly interested in human factors.
The interesting question is often not:
“What was the final mistake?”
It is:
At what earlier point could somebody have noticed the direction things were heading?
My St Abbs exit was a good example
My first open-water drysuit experience at St Abbs gave me a very physical example of small decisions interacting.
I had been significantly overweighted.
That meant more gas in the drysuit.
More gas made the hover harder.
More ballast also meant more weight to carry out of the water.
Then we had a rocky exit with a one-to-two metre swell.
Somebody tried to help and grabbed the corrugated inflator hose on my XDEEP wing.
The hose disconnected.
I went back underwater and surfaced with a wing containing a substantial quantity of North Sea.
None of this requires a villain.
The person helping me was genuinely trying to help.
Afterwards, while repairing the wing before the second dive, we simply talked about safer places to grab a diver wearing that equipment.
Tank valve.
Shoulder straps.
Lesson learned.
Critique the decision pathway, not the person
That has become an important rule for how I want to discuss diving incidents.
Critique the decision pathway, not the person.
Calling somebody stupid does not teach me anything.
Understanding what information they had, what pressure they were under, what assumptions were being made and what options appeared available might.
The goal should not be:
“I would never do that.”
It should be:
“What would make me vulnerable to making the same decision?”
That is a much less comfortable question.
It is also a much more useful one.
Safety culture matters
The same principle applies beyond individual divers.
During one training trip I heard comments that concerned me about how medical declarations were being treated around inexperienced divers.
I raised what I had heard with the centre.
I cannot know what happened afterwards.
But the experience changed how I think about choosing training organisations.
Previously, I probably thought instructor first.
Now I think instructor and culture.
A very good instructor working inside a system whose safety standards concern me still leaves me with something I need to assess.
Raising a concern should not require somebody to feel disloyal or afraid of causing trouble.
Healthy safety cultures should want to know when something feels wrong.
Being teachable matters too
Stop. Think. Assess is not just something I want to use when I believe somebody else is making the wrong decision.
It has to apply to my own assumptions too.
Drysuit buoyancy is a good example.
At the moment I primarily use the suit for buoyancy underwater and the wing at the surface.
As I move towards technical training, I may work with instructors who want me to use a different method.
If an instructor tells me to use the wing as my primary buoyancy device, I want to understand why.
But while I am under their tuition, I will practise the method they are teaching.
Afterwards, I can assess the reasoning and experience and decide what makes sense for my own diving.
Learn the reasoning. Practise the method. Then decide from experience rather than habit.
Confidence should create more pauses, not fewer
As I have become more confident underwater, I have noticed something slightly unexpected.
I want to dive more slowly.
Rescue made me more willing to approach somebody who might be struggling.
Deep training made me more interested in gas, time and what actually justifies going deeper.
Drysuit training made me think ahead about buoyancy changes.
Moving to a backplate-and-wing made me look at equipment placement and unnecessary task loading.
None of those things has made me want to rush.
They have made me more comfortable pausing.
I increasingly think that is what useful confidence looks like.
The framework I am trying to build into every dive
STOP
Something has changed.
Interrupt the momentum long enough to notice it.
THINK
What do I actually know?
What am I assuming?
ASSESS
What are the risks?
What options are available?
What is the easiest safe next step?
ACT
Make the decision.
Continue, change the plan, regroup, ascend or call the dive.
PAUSE
Give the decision time to take effect.
REPEAT
Has the situation improved?
If not, start again.
Final thought
Stop. Think. Assess is not a revolutionary system.
That is probably why I like it.
It is deliberately simple enough that I can remember it when the dive stops being simple.
It reminds me that I do not need perfect information before I start thinking.
I do not need to wait until something becomes an emergency before I change the plan.
And I do not need to blame somebody afterwards in order to learn from what happened.
Most importantly, it gives me permission to pause.
Because the earlier I notice that the dive is starting to change, the more options I usually still have.
Stop. Think. Assess. Act. Pause. Repeat.